Increasingly, fisheries researchers and managers seek or are compelled to “bridge”
Indigenous knowledge systems with Western scientific approaches to understanding
and governing fisheries. Here, we move beyond the all-too-common narrative about
integrating or incorporating (too often used as euphemisms for assimilating) other
knowledge systems into Western science, instead of building an ethic of knowledge
coexistence and complementarity in knowledge generation using Two-Eyed Seeing
as a guiding framework. Two-Eyed Seeing (Etuaptmumk in Mi’kmaw) embraces “learning
to see from one eye with the strengths of Indigenous knowledges and ways of
knowing, and from the other eye with the strengths of mainstream knowledges and
ways of knowing, and to use both these eyes together, for the benefit of all,” as envisaged
by Elder Dr. Albert Marshall. In this paper, we examine the notion of knowledge
dichotomies and imperatives for knowledge coexistence and draw parallels between
Two-Eyed Seeing and other analogous Indigenous frameworks from around the
world. It is set apart from other Indigenous frameworks in its explicit action imperative—
central to Two-Eyed Seeing is the notion that knowledge transforms the holder
and that the holder bears a responsibility to act on that knowledge. We explore its
operationalization through three Canadian aquatic and fisheries case-studies that
co-develop questions, document and mobilize knowledge, and co-produce insights
and decisions. We argue that Two-Eyed Seeing provides a pathway to a plural coexistence,
where time-tested Indigenous knowledge systems can be paired with, not
subsumed by, Western scientific insights for an equitable and sustainable future.
co-production, Etuaptmumk, indigenous knowledge, knowledge coexistence, pluralism,
Western science
Featured Resources
Simone Athayde, Jose Silva-Lugo, Marianne Schmink, Aturi Kaiabi, Michael Heckenberger
2017 | South America
Sustainability science focuses on generating and applying knowledge to environmentally sound human development around the world. It requires working toward greater integration of different types of knowledge, ways of knowing, and between academy and society. We contribute to the development of approaches for learning from indigenous knowledge, through enhanced understanding…
Hanna Guttorm, Lea Kantonen, Britt Kramvig, Aili Pyhälä
2021 | Europe
In this chapter we want to bring Indigenous ontologies and ways of knowing into the practices of decolonized research-storying. One implication about that is bringing Eana, Earth in North Sámi, as a narrator into the text. This text is a collaborative endeavour, where we write about and with our encountering…
Olivia E.T. Yates, Shiloh Groot, Sam Manuela, Andreas Neef
2023 | Aotearoa New Zealand
Background and Aims: Many Pacific people are considering cross‐border mobility in response to the climate crisis, despite exclusion from international protection frameworks. The ‘Migration with dignity’ concept facilitates immigration within existing laws but without host government support. Through the metaphor of Pacific navigation, we explore the role of dignity in…
Freya Higgins-Desbiolles
2022 | Australia
Recent work in development studies asked: “whatever happened to the idea of imperialism?”This article will analyse the ongoingness of imperialism in order to illuminate sources of injusticeand inequity in tourism. It will also delve into historical understandings of the capacities oftourism in a time when revolutionary, decolonising leadership looked to…
Featured Resources
Simone Athayde, Jose Silva-Lugo, Marianne Schmink, Aturi Kaiabi, Michael Heckenberger
2017 | South America
Sustainability science focuses on generating and applying knowledge to environmentally sound human development around the world. It requires working toward greater integration of different types of knowledge, ways of knowing, and between academy and society. We contribute to the development of approaches for learning from indigenous knowledge, through enhanced understanding…
Hanna Guttorm, Lea Kantonen, Britt Kramvig, Aili Pyhälä
2021 | Europe
In this chapter we want to bring Indigenous ontologies and ways of knowing into the practices of decolonized research-storying. One implication about that is bringing Eana, Earth in North Sámi, as a narrator into the text. This text is a collaborative endeavour, where we write about and with our encountering…
Olivia E.T. Yates, Shiloh Groot, Sam Manuela, Andreas Neef
2023 | Aotearoa New Zealand
Background and Aims: Many Pacific people are considering cross‐border mobility in response to the climate crisis, despite exclusion from international protection frameworks. The ‘Migration with dignity’ concept facilitates immigration within existing laws but without host government support. Through the metaphor of Pacific navigation, we explore the role of dignity in…
Freya Higgins-Desbiolles
2022 | Australia
Recent work in development studies asked: “whatever happened to the idea of imperialism?”This article will analyse the ongoingness of imperialism in order to illuminate sources of injusticeand inequity in tourism. It will also delve into historical understandings of the capacities oftourism in a time when revolutionary, decolonising leadership looked to…